Hi, my name’s Donna, and I’m a mushroom-aholic.
When I was a kid, I loved mushrooms, whether they were canned or fresh. Yes, I was the weird kid who loved all sort of vegetables.
Later, When I was off on my own, I found a mushroom farm not to far from where I lived. I’d go there just about every week and pick up three or four pounds of mushrooms. Every week.
I’ve cut back on that a bit. In fact, I don’t buy mushrooms every week. But although I’ve cut back in volume, I’ve increased the diversity of the mushrooms that I use. Back when I had the four-pound-a-week habit, it was mostly white mushrooms, and sometimes there would also be some brown ones. But no exotic varieties.
Now, there’s a stand at the farmer’s market that sells a pretty interesting variety of mushrooms. And of course I have my stash of dried mushrooms.
But even though I’ve expanded my mushroom horizons, I still like standard white or brown mushrooms for many things. The top of a pizza for example. Cream of mushroom soup.
Or for pickling. Particularly for pickling. If you’re going to pickle a mushroom, you’re going to add a LOT of flavor from the pickling liquid, so there’s no sense in using an exotic (and expensive) variety.
When it comes to pickled mushrooms, you can opt to slice your mushrooms, leave them whole, or cut them in halves or quarters. It depends, in part, on how big the mushrooms are. Slices will pickle faster than whole mushrooms, so if you need them soon, slicing or quartering makes sense. It also depends on what you plan on using them for. If they’re destined for a tray of nibbles, the whole ones make sense. But if you’re using them as a condiment, slices might make more sense.
These pickled mushrooms have a nice kick to them and a slightly smoky flavor. They make a great topping for sandwiches, burgers or tacos. You can also add them to a stir-fry, scrambled eggs, or cook them briefly along with your fajita ingredients.
Quick-Pickled No-Fuss Spicy Mushrooms
- 1/2 pound fresh mushrooms, cleaned

- 1/2 small onion, medium dice
- 1/4 cup Captain Spongefoot Steak Wash
- Juice of 1/2 lemon
Slice, halve or quarter the mushrooms, if desired. Combine all the ingredients in a nonreactive container. Stir to coat the mushrooms. Refrigerate at least a couple hours, or up to several days. It’s a good idea to give the container a little shake once in a while, or open it up and stir things around, to make sure all the mushrooms are getting equal time in the marinating mixture.
If you prefer, you can put the mixture into a plastic bag and squeeze out as much air as possible. Then put the bag in a bowl (because if you don’t the bag will leak. If it’s in the bowl to catch drips, chances are you won’t lose a drop.)
Serve cold, room temperature, or warm them up, if you prefer.
Get Our Free Cookbook

Do you love eating real food as much as we do? Then you should have a copy of our free cookbook!
It’s filled with recipes inspired by some of the country’s most creative food artisans.
Donna Currie is a Colorado-based food writer who operates the blog Cookistry.